Campus ID News
Card, mobile credential, payment and security
FEATURED
PARTNERS
Voting sign

Appeals court rescinds use of Chapel Hill’s mobile credential for voter ID

Reasons given for why Chapel Hill originally approved but Duke and UNC Charlotte denied

CampusIDNews Staff   ||   Oct 04, 2024  ||   ,

The state of North Carolina requires voters to show and approved form of ID to cast a ballot, and university-issued mobile credentials have taken center stage. Many traditional campus cards are approved, but three institutions in the state use a digital ID rather than a card.

UNC Chapel Hill, UNC Charlotte, and Duke University each talked with or applied to the State Board of Elections about having their mobile IDs added to the list. UNC Chapel Hill’s request was approved, but for a variety of reasons, the others were ineligible.

Some mobile IDs approved, other denied

There is a requirement in North Carolina that approved voter IDs must display an expiration date. Mobile credentials stored in Apple Wallet can display an expiration date using a custom field. This capability, however, is not currently supported by Google Wallet.

Duke and UNC Charlotte offer students the choice of storing their credential natively in the Wallet on either device type, so this would have left a portion of the population – those using Android phones – with an unaccepted device.

Chapel Hill, however, does not allow storage of a credential natively in Google Wallet, so they elected to only request authorization for the iOS users. Android users can come to the card office and request a physical card if they choose to do so.

Duke and UNC Charlotte offer students the choice of storing their credential natively in the Wallet on either device type, so this would have left a portion of the population – those using Android phones – with an unaccepted device.

Charlotte students that are still using a physical card can use it for voting as the cards include an expiration date. A university spokesperson told CampusIDNews that students must choose between a card or mobile ID as they are not permitted to have both. Currently 97% of incoming students choose the mobile option. Thus, only a small number of new students have the accepted card.

At Duke, the physical card did not have an expiration date. To serve students that did not have another approved ID to vote, the DukeCard office offered a new voting version of the DukeCard complete with an expiration date.

Another issue for the Duke mobile ID was that there was not a process in place to verify the individual’s photo at the time of submission. This also rendered the ID unusable according to state requirements.

The on-again off-again acceptance of the Chapel Hill mobile ID

On August 20, the North Carolina State Board or Elections narrowly approved Chapel Hill’s request along party lines – Democrats in favor and Republicans opposed. This began a series of twists, turns, and legal wranglings.

The Republican National Committee and the North Carolina Republican Party quickly filed a lawsuit against the State Board of Elections to overturn the decision.


Timeline:

  • Aug. 20: State Board of Elections approves the use of UNC Chapel Hill’s mobile credential as an approved form of voter ID
  • Sept. 12: Republican National Committee and the North Carolina Republican Party sues State Board of Elections to overturn the decision
  • Sept. 19: North Carolina judge denied the requested temporary restraining order, thus refusing to block the use of the UNC digital ID
  • Sept. 27: North Carolina Court of Appeals reversed the decision, eliminating the mobile ID from the list of approved voter IDs

In addition to questioning the security of the credentials, they pointed out that the statute specifically cited ID “cards” multiple times but never mentioned digital or mobile IDs. Thus, they argued that the decision was not up to the Board of Elections but instead required legislative review.

The following week, a North Carolina judge denied the Republican’s request for a temporary restraining order. The UNC mobile ID had passed its second hurdle and could be used.

But not for long.

The Republicans appealed, and the North Carolina Court of Appeals reversed the lower court’s decision. The mobile ID was removed from the list of approved voter IDs at the end of September.

Preparing your campus credentials for voter ID

While this must be frustrating for those who worked hard to make this possible, their work will help future institutions navigate the voter ID process.

Years ago, most campuses eliminated expiration dates from physical cards to reduce the need for replacement cards for long term students and staff. With a mobile credential, an expiration can be included and it can be updated in future years.

Working to ensure an expiration date is included on your mobile credential seems like an obvious step. Similarly, if voter ID is important to your institution, you should at least evaluate adding expiration dates to physical cards.

Working to ensure an expiration date is included on your mobile credential seems like an obvious step. Similarly, if voter ID is important to your institution, you should at least evaluate adding expiration dates to physical cards.

Requiring a government-issued ID or similar proof of identity with a photo should also be strongly considered – both for voter ID purposes but also for general security and ID integrity issues.

Stay informed with changes to your state’s voter ID regulations so that you can proactively address requirements in advance. Of course, this will not always be possible because the partisan nature of the issue means that requirements will likely continue to change rapidly.

Related Posts

|| TAGS:
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

RECENT ARTICLES

view of cafeteria with empty seats
Nov 14, 24 /

Cards, apps, data fight food insecurity on campus

Food insecurity, defined as a lack of reliable access to enough food, affects students’ focus, grades, and likelihood of completing their studies due to increased stress, anxiety, and financial strain. The need to choose between food and other essentials like textbooks creates a cycle of poverty that can impact both academic and social development. A […]
phone in hand
Nov 13, 24 / , ,

Making mobile credentials pay off

Institutions tend to focus on the cost of transitioning to mobile credentials, such as upfront infrastructure, annual license fees for credentials, and loss of replacement card fees.  But mobile can offer both significant savings and the chance to reimagine revenue streams. To help crystalize these opportunities, the University of Alabama’s Courtney Petrizzi, outlined a series […]
NACCU 2025 Annual Conference
Nov 07, 24 /

Become a Presenter at the NACCU 2025 Annual Conference in Nevada

The NACCU 2025 Annual Conference will take place in Henderson, Nevada, from April 6 to April 9, 2025. This annual event brings together campus card professionals from across the country, offering a platform for learning, networking, and sharing industry best practices. As part of the conference’s educational program, NACCU is calling for proposals from both […]
CIDN logo reversed
The only publication dedicated to the use of campus cards, mobile credentials, identity and security technology in the education market. CampusIDNews – formerly CR80News – has served more than 6,500 subscribers for more than two decades.
Twitter

Attn: friends in the biometrics space. Nominations close Friday for the annual Women in Biometrics Awards. Take five minutes to recognize a colleague or even yourself. http://WomenInBiometrics.com

Feb. 1 webinar explores how mobile ordering enhanced campus life, increased sales at UVA and Central Washington @Grubhub @CBORD

Load More...
Contact
CampusIDNews is published by AVISIAN Publishing
315 E. Georgia St.
Tallahassee, FL 32301
www.AVISIAN.com[email protected]
Use our contact form to submit tips, corrections, or questions to our team.
©2024 CampusIDNews. All rights reserved.